7 Best Self Tanner Consumer Reports 2019 – Top Rated

Life has a tendency of getting in the way of all our best plans and goals. You may want the healthy glow of tanned skin but you can’t always make it to the beach to chill. Honestly, who can? Tanning beds or professional spray tans offer a more timely alternative but that’s still a time commitment a lot of us just can’t make. A self-tanner is the solution that most can appreciate as it requires the least initial time and upkeep time. And let’s not make light of the risk of skin cancer that is negated by protecting yourself in the shade.

Top 7 Self Tanner

Bestseller No. 1
St. TROPEZ Self Tan Bronzing Mousse, 8 fl. oz.
1710 Reviews
St. TROPEZ Self Tan Bronzing Mousse, 8 fl. oz.
  • Velvety smooth and dry in an instant for an ultra even, long-lasting tan
  • Innovative Aromaguard fragrance technology eliminates the tell-tale self tan aroma by a...
SaleBestseller No. 2
Self Tanner with Organic & Natural Ingredients, Tanning Lotion, Sunless Tanning Lotion for Flawless Darker Bronzer Skin, Self Tanning Lotion - Self Tanners Best Sellers, Fake Tan
3633 Reviews
Self Tanner with Organic & Natural Ingredients, Tanning Lotion, Sunless Tanning Lotion for Flawless Darker Bronzer Skin, Self Tanning Lotion - Self Tanners Best Sellers, Fake Tan
  • SAY HELLO TO PERFECT SUN KISSED SKIN: Our self tanner transforms your skin. This vegan...
  • GET YOUR TAN WITHOUT THE SUN DAMAGE OR CHEMICALS: There's a reason this is one of the best...
SaleBestseller No. 3
Fake Bake Flawless, 6 fl.oz
6450 Reviews
Fake Bake Flawless, 6 fl.oz
  • This tropical scented, non-sticky formula dries quickly for a beautiful, glowing tan that...
  • Fake Bake has a built-in color guide so you can see where you're applying the self-tanning...
SaleBestseller No. 4
Jergens Natural Glow +FIRMING Daily Moisturizer for Body, Fair to Medium Skin Tones, 7.5 Ounces
900 Reviews
Jergens Natural Glow +FIRMING Daily Moisturizer for Body, Fair to Medium Skin Tones, 7.5 Ounces
  • Gradually creates flawless, natural-looking color while hydrating skin, even when the...
  • Developed to subtly enhance and gradually deepen the natural skin tone, providing...
SaleBestseller No. 5
Jergens Natural Glow Instant Sun Sunless Tanning Mousse for Body, Deep Bronze, 6 Ounces
937 Reviews
Jergens Natural Glow Instant Sun Sunless Tanning Mousse for Body, Deep Bronze, 6 Ounces
  • Instantly creates a flawless, natural-looking tan, even when the beach is miles (or...
  • With Advanced Color Complex, the airy mousse works with your skin's natural tone to mimic...
SaleBestseller No. 6
Skinerals Self Tanner Sunless Bronzer Californium Natural and Organic Ingredients for Safe Alternative to Sun Tanning for Body and Face (8 Ounce)
1896 Reviews
Skinerals Self Tanner Sunless Bronzer Californium Natural and Organic Ingredients for Safe Alternative to Sun Tanning for Body and Face (8 Ounce)
  • Safe for use on face and body for a beautiful, natural, consistent tan. *Tanning mitt sold...
  • Cruelty-free, Sulfate-free, Paraben-free, Vegan, Made in USA. Natural-looking, sun-kissed...
Bestseller No. 7
Self Tanner Instant Ultra Dark 8 fl oz, Sunless Tanning Lotion and Self Bronzer | Sunless Bronzing Cream | Instant, Quick-Drying, Streak-Free, Fair To Medium Skin Tones (Packaging May Very)
1622 Reviews
Self Tanner Instant Ultra Dark 8 fl oz, Sunless Tanning Lotion and Self Bronzer | Sunless Bronzing Cream | Instant, Quick-Drying, Streak-Free, Fair To Medium Skin Tones (Packaging May Very)
  • FORMULATED WITH A NATURAL BLEND OF INGREDIENTS - We have searched the farthest regions of...
  • CELEBRITIES LOVE IT, DOCTORS RECOMMEND IT Sun Laboratories Sunless Tanning lotions (also...

Important Features to Consider

A self-tanner should do several things well. Here’s what to consider when selecting a self-tanner for your skin:

  • Natural, DHA or melanin bronzers. Natural bronzers will use natural plant and herbal ingredients to color the skin, like makeup and will last just a day or two, so you’ll need to apply frequently. DHA bronzers use DHA to react to the dead layer of skin and increase your skin’s darkness; the more DHA in the tanner, the darker bronze you’ll have. (Most tanners are DHA tanners.) They’ll typically last just under a week and the results are visible two to four hours after application. Melanin bronzers enhance the synthesis of melanin in your skin. Since melanin is the darker pigment in your skin, (and hair and eyes) promoting more production will give you a darker appearance. These are the lowest maintenance self-tanners.
  • Tan extenders. This will very often be an additional feature of a lot of tanners because it will help prolong your tanning results. It essentially just boosts the moisture of your skin with a vitamin-enriched formula. It will keep the tanned skin from shedding as quickly. If you have a tanner with the extender, then you’ll still just apply as recommended but if you purchase a tan extender without the self-tanning feature, you’ll want to apply it daily or after any shower or bath.
  • Moisturizers and lotions. Choosing a moisturizing tanner will be a great option if you want to have a fast, daily routine. The DHA content is significantly lower and perfect for daily use, allowing the tan to build over time. (This is also a great way to “fake” gradual tanning as if you had been beach-bound daily.) It’s an excellent choice for beginners or just those who don’t want to overthink it. Lotions will often include a tint so you’ll be able to catch if you’ve missed a spot right away.
  • Towelettes. The part about towelettes you’ll love the best is that it’s almost impossible to over apply when using them. They’re a simple upkeep kind of application that is perfect to pack on any kind of vacation or road trip to maintain the glorious tan (even if it’s a sunless tan) you’ve built up. It will have the exact amount of tanner you’ll need and you won’t need to worry about the mess that tanners can sometimes cause.
  • Sprays. With a spray that you apply to your own body, you’ll need to stay consistent in the application. You’ll need to apply it evenly and at about a 6″ distance from your skin. Because of this, it’s not for beginners or those with sloppy technique. You will likely want to hone your spray-tan skills, though. How else do you really plan on self-tanning your back? Even if you opt for a tanner with less precise application requirements, you may still be best off using this, also, at least for your hard to reach places.
  • Mousses, gels, and serums. These are all tanners that require applications at a more experienced level. If you’ve been applying your own tanner for years, then this is an alternative that may feel better on your skin. You can put thin layers on your skin to make it a bit easier to coat evenly and build over time, but you will want to make sure your self-tan game is strong before you jump into this tanner. They usually won’t show how well you’ve blended before it is absorbed into the skin and an uneven streaky appearance is definitely not outside the realm of possibility.

What is self-tanner and how does it work? A self-tanner is a product that will darken the appearance of your skin without exposing you to the harmful UV rays of sunlight. It will very likely use dihydroxyacetone (DHA) to react to your skin cells on the surface and darken your skin. You can apply it in several different ways: Sprays and lotions are the most common, but you can also use a serum, mousse, gel, or towelette. Each has their perks and you may find what’s best for your skin isn’t what’s best for others and you may just need to experiment a bit to find your perfect fit.

How long does spray on tan last?

How long your self-tanner lasts depends on what type of tanner you use. Most are going to affect the skin it touches, and that means the tan will only go skin deep. You shed skin every day and not always evenly, so you’ll find no matter what your choice of sunless tanner, you’ll need to upkeep it on a regular basis and in order to do so, you’ll have to follow the instructions for that specific product. Sometimes you’ll need to upkeep it daily and other times you can push it for up to a week.

Leave a Reply